Functional data structures in common lisp essay

Function and macro calls are written as lists, with the name of the function first, as in these examples: The asterisks are part of ; the name.

Functional data structures in common lisp essay

Dijkstra introduces the topic of his letter, which is that he has noticed that goto statements are mostly detrimental to the programs in which they appear. He proposes that goto statements should be abolished from all high-level programming languages.

My first Functional data structures in common lisp essay is that, although the programmer's activity ends when he has constructed a correct program, the process taking place under control of his program is the true subject matter of his activity, for it is this process that has to accomplish the desired effect; it is this process that in its dynamic behavior has to satisfy the desired specifications.

Yet, once the program has been made, the "making" of the corresponding process is delegated to the machine. This paragraph of technically dense verbiage is fairly typical of Dijkstra's academic writing style.

This just means that the actual activity performed by a programmer is not simply writing programs, but controlling the action of the code as it is executed on an actual machine.

However, he states, once the programmer has written a working program, the actual execution of the program is entirely under the control of the machine itself. Dijkstra uses the term correct to describe a program that has no errors, or in current parlance, has no bugs. This terminology reflects the belief at the time that code could be written which could be formally verified, i.

My second remark is that our intellectual powers are rather geared to master static relations and that our powers to visualize processes evolving in time are relatively poorly developed. For that reason we should do as wise programmers aware of our limitations our utmost to shorten the conceptual gap between the static program and the dynamic process, to make the correspondence between the program spread out in text space and the process spread out in time as trivial as possible.

Here Dijkstra observes that humans are better at visualizing static relationships than dynamic relationships. Thus, he argues, we should minimize the difference between the two when expressed as program code, so that the dynamic nonconstant aspects of the program are evident in the structure of the source code itself.

Table of Contents

This is generally true in most current programming languages, the majority of which operate in a linear, statement-by-statement fashion.

However, to some extent Dijkstra's principle has not been fully realized when we observe the complexity that must be dealt with by real-world programming tasks, such as multitasking, multithreading, interrupt handling, volatile hardware registers, virtual memory paging, device latency, real-time event handling, and so forth, just to name a few.

Today's programming problems are no longer sufficiently handled by simple one-line-at-a-time execution programming models. Let us now consider how we can characterize the progress of a process. You may think about this question in a very concrete manner: Dijkstra begins to construct a formal definition of program execution, or what he calls progress of a process.

It must be remembered that many of the terms we take for granted today were not firmly established place at the time, and there was no commonly accepted language or pseudo-language in use for discusing algorithms and programs. Today, of course, a writer would use a concrete language such as C, Java, Pascal, LISP, or a pseudo-language bearing a strong resemblance to one of these languages as a lingua franca for illustrating programming concepts.

Let us call such a pointer to a suitable place in the text a "textual index.

The End of Moore’s Law – Rodney Brooks

This reflects the dual nature of programming tasks that he mentioned previously, these being related to the sequential nature of executing one statement or action after another, i.

His term textual index is essentially a program counter. However, he is attempting to go beyond simply tracking the location of the current execution thread, to making an explicit connection between a statement in the source code text and a program execution state. Dijkstra introduces more complex flow control statements such as if-then-else conditional statements and case a.

This reflects the fact that, at the time, much effort was being made to formulate the best minimal set of flow control structures for programming languages and for programming theory in general. A major goal of all of this effort was to create a nomeclature that could be used not just for actual programming languages, but which also could be used directly for mathematical formulations of programming algorithms.


As soon as we include in our language procedures we must admit that a single textual index is no longer sufficient. With the inclusion of procedures we can characterize the progress of the process via a sequence of textual indices, the length of this sequence being equal to the dynamic depth of procedure calling.

Functional data structures in common lisp essay

This is an observation that a single statement pointer is not sufficient to define the state of an executing program if the program employs subroutines variously known as procedures, functions, or methods. This reflects what is known in modern parlance as a call stack, which is an array of program counters a.

Since he is establishing an explicit relation between a textual index and the program execution state, though, it would be more correct to think of the call stack as an array of statement pointers.Hafta 14 Derin Öğrenme: Derin Öğrenme (Deep Learning) Yapay Sinir Ağlarına Giriş (Artificial Neural Networks) Aktivasyon Fonksiyonları (Activation Functions).

AFH Carib/Ameri Connections in Lit. Undergraduate 3 credits. DEC: G SBC: HFA+.

Data structures in functional programming - Software Engineering Stack Exchange

An exploration of the connections between writers from the French-speaking and English-speaking Caribbean and from the African-American community, who share a similar cultural heritage, historical heritage, and historical experience, but differ in geopolitical situations.

CLOSED: Mon This post on the limits of introspection posits that: Mental processes are the results of opaque preferences, and our own "introspected" goals and preferences are a product of the same machinery that infers goals and preferences in others in order to predict their behavior.

April , rev. April (This article is derived from a talk given at the Franz Developer Symposium.) In the summer of , my friend Robert Morris and I started a startup called plan was to write software that would let end users build online stores.

As far as I'm concerned, Ocaml, F#, and the like are imperative languages with functional data structures. But as I said in my answer, I don't believe there's any objective, non-ambiguous answer to this question.

The graph reminds me of Alexander Pope’s “Essay on Criticism”, warning “A little learning is a dangerous thing; Drink deep, or taste not the Pierian spring.”.

Functional data structures in common lisp essay
The APL Programming Language Source Code | @CHM Blog | Computer History Museum